Reflections on Glimmerglass

Celebrating 25 years of the Glimmerglass Historic District

Exhibition at The Smithy, July 2 - August 30, 2025
On view Tuesdays-Saturdays, 11 am to 4 pm

Otsego Lake from Cooperstown with sky reflected in lake

The Glimmerglass Historic District is notable not only for its remarkably intact 19th and early 20th century architecture clustered around the lake, but even more so because it was among the first national historic districts to recognize the singularly beautiful natural landscape as integral to the community’s development over time.  Otsego Lake and its hillsides, the ancestral lands of the Haudenosaunee, have inspired countless artists and writers since William Cooper first laid claim to its southern shore. His son James Fenimore Cooper’s The Leatherstocking Tales, with its vivid poetic descriptions of forest, lake, and fen, attracted travelers and tourists to the region beginning in the second half of the 19th century, leading to the development of the camps, inns, boardinghouses, and parks that we know today.

Cooper was arguably the first American novelist to espouse the notion that nature was not something to be feared or tamed or exploited, but to be respected as critical to human survival. His descendant Henry S.F. Cooper, Jr., founder of Otsego 2000, argued that Cooper’s novels sparked the environmental movement at a time when industrialization was emerging as nature’s biggest threat.

Now, nearly 200 years after the novelist first coined “Glimmerglass” in The Deerslayer, this exhibit celebrates 25 years of the Glimmerglass National Historic District, placed on the New York State and National Registers of Historic Places in 1999 as a remarkably intact 19th century cultural landscape. The exhibit showcases works by contemporary local artists inspired by Otsego Lake, juxtaposed with historic images taken by William G. Smith and Arthur “Putt” Telfer, who together chronicled daily life in Cooperstown and on the lake for nearly a century, from 1850 to 1950. Thank you to all who submitted photographs for the community art installation, confirming the lake’s special hold on all who experience it.

We invite you to reflect on what Otsego Lake and its views inspire in you.

The Reflections on Glimmerglass exhibit, curated by Otsego 2000, was made possible by a grant from the C.J. Heilig Foundation.

Featured Artists:

  • Dianne Bordley

  • Ann Murdoch Geiger

  • Cleve Gray

  • Deborah Geurtze

  • Maureen Heroux

  • Megan Adams Irving

  • Peter Johngren

  • May-Britt Joyce

  • Julie Huntsman

  • William Jay Miller

  • Mary Nolan

  • Bart Norton

  • Sam Ross

  • Susan Fenimore Cooper Weil

  • Vicki Whicker

  • Cheryl Wright

The Smithy is located at 55 Pioneer Street, Cooperstown, NY.

“A Masterpiece of Nature”

-Henry S.F. Cooper, Jr.

Beginning in the 1850s, and continuing to the present day, generations of local leaders – most prominently, the Clark and Cooper families – have worked to ensure that Otsego Lake and its surrounding countryside remain “a masterpiece of nature,” as Henry S.F. Cooper, Jr. deemed it, for present and future generations.

Otsego 2000 continues that mission. Founded in 1981 as Friends of P.R.O.T.E.C.T, the environmental and preservation advocacy nonprofit works to protect and enhance the well-being of the land, resources, and people of the Otsego Lake region.

In the late 1990s, recognizing that development threats were not going away, Otsego 2000 spearheaded the effort to nominate Otsego Lake, its hillsides and historic buildings, and the Village of Cooperstown, to the State and National Registers of Historic Places. This astounding feat of community collaboration was led by Otsego 2000 chair Henry Cooper, executive directors Polly Renckens and Martha Frey, attorney Robert Poulson, historian Jessie Ravage, local municipal officials, New York State Office of Parks, Recreation, and Historic Preservation Commissioner Bernadette Castro, New York State National Register Coordinator Kathleen LaFrank, and many others. More than 2,200 structures and 15,000 acres were photographed, mapped (by hand!), and documented.

The Glimmerglass Historic District affords an extra level of protection to Otsego Lake from state and federal infrastructure projects and adverse development on its shores or in its viewshed. At the same time, owners of historic homes have benefitted from state historic property tax credits, with nearly $1 million in tax credits returning to Otsego County since the credit was established, illustrating just one way preservation makes economic sense.

Our Glimmerglass

Otsego 2000 asked community members to submit favorite photos of Otsego Lake and the Glimmerglass Historic District to be featured in the Reflections on Glimmerglass exhibit.

More photos will be added to this online gallery each week.

The Rural Hours Project

In 1848, the writer Susan Fenimore Cooper, began a nature journal that, two years later, would be published as the book Rural Hours.

Cooperstown Village Historian Will Walker has started The Rural Hours Project to share entries from Cooper’s work along with his own nature observations from walks and runs around Cooperstown.

Find out more about the Glimmerglass Historic District

The New York State Cultural Resource Information System (CRIS) is a searchable database of historic buildings, structures, sites, and surveys. The site also includes the National Register of Historic Places 1999 Form for the Glimmerglass Historic District.

Community Art Project

Get Involved

How You Can Protect Otsego Lake

Otsego Lake and its surrounding towns and village benefit from a strong network of environmental organizations working to protect and preserve the natural and historic resources we all treasure. We encourage you to get involved through participating in programs and citizen science projects, volunteering, serving on boards, and donating to ensure these organizations are able to continue their important work.

“What’s been true is that over the last 25 years the beauty of this place, more or less natural 19th century landscape, has been under one challenge after another from various outside sources.”

Henry S.F. Cooper, Jr., in “Henry Cooper’s Town,” by Sophie Hays
New York States of Mind, January 21, 2014